Review: The Golden Compass Tuesday December 18, 2007, 6 comments

I just went and saw The Golden Compass, a feature-film adaptation of the first installment of Philip Pullman’s His Dark Materials trilogy. I ready these books a few years ago during the long lull between books four and five of the illustrious Harry Potter series, and was very impressed. Pullman tapped into christian mythology in a creative and innovative way, and managed to merge the fantasy and science-fiction genres beautifully.

I had seen a trailer for the movie in which gold-gilt airships featured prominently. I am a huge fan of dirigibles, and so was particularly excited about the visuals I had seen. I sat down in the theatre with a sense of excitement.

Let me sum it up. The movie was good, but not at all the movie I was expecting to see. The visuals were, as I had anticipated, amazing. The airships were fantastic, though a bit rare. Lyra’s Oxford and London were brilliant. The armored bears were, in a word, spectacular.

Some of the casting choices were inspired, other’s somewhat unexpected. Nicole Kidman as Ms. Coulter was an excellent choice. When I first saw her in the trailer, I was immediately sure she was the right choice. Sam Elliot was a better Lee Scoresby than the one in my imagination. Dakota Blue Richards gave me cause for concern at first, but she pulled off Lyra brilliantly. The ubiquitous Christopher Lee made a brief appearance as the First High Councilor, and Ian McKellen voiced Iorek Byrnison. Sarumon and Gandalf all over again, why mess with great chemistry?

The makers of the movie made some very wholesale changes. An entire race of people (the Samoyeds) were added. The anti-church rhetoric was definitely softened, and many important plot elements were modified or lost completely. Two major plot sections were switched. The entire Bolvanger scene was moved till after the Svalbard, resulting in a plot hole not quite large enough to guide a battalion of armored bears through.

But most disturbingly, the entire end of the book was sacrificed to the gods of suspense. It is obvious they are planning to make the next two books into movies, but leaving the movie at the point where they did would have been like Peter Jackson leaving the Fellowship of the Ring off while the party was standing in front of the gates to Moria. An interesting place to stop, but not at all the one anyone would have been expecting.

All that aside, the movie was quite enjoyable. It is imperative to go into a movie based upon a book with an open mind, as changes are inevitably made. If you’ve read and loved the books, or listened to the BBC dramatization, you might find yourself puzzled, but if you’ve never picked up any of the trilogy, go see the movie, then head on down to Indigo and pick up the books.

Then let me know if you, too, find yourself hoping there’ll be more airships in the next movie.


sarah Tuesday December 18, 2007

I felt that they took a basic 101 level of film-making/scriptwriting and imposed it on a story that was fortunately good enough to shine through.

Adrian Tuesday December 18, 2007

That seems a pretty accurate statement, overall.

cristina Thursday December 20, 2007

I heard good and bad things about the movie, but I’m not inclined to see it at all. The one movie that I really want to see with my boyfriend is “I Am Legend”. I mean, I don’t really care for Will Smith, but any movie that does better than the “Lord Of The Rings” whatever movie it was, I consider a must see. No, I never saw “Rings”.

Adrian Friday December 21, 2007

Well, I can’t help but recommend Rings. It was brilliantly done.

I am Legend sounds interesting, but I didn’t know much about the movie before seeing the posters in the movie theatre. I guess not watching television does impact one’s exposure to pop culture.

The Golden Compass was good. That’s the long and short of it.

I enjoyed it.

Heather Saturday December 22, 2007

I Am Legend has a big Christian agenda from what I’ve read. This lead one reviewer to ask why there isn’t a warning – as in, ‘May contain scenes of graphic violence, nudity and themes of Christianity.’

Adrian Saturday December 22, 2007

Again,I barely know anything about I am Legend. I know Will Smith is in it, and that it looks somewhat post-apocalyptical.

Other than that, I dunno.

I have no trouble with Christian themes in movies, if the themes are integral to a GOOD story.

If its just there to peddle religion…

Screw it.

Commenting has ended for this post, but I'd still love to hear from you.

The website of Adrian Lebar

A Rain of Frogs is written, designed and built by Adrian Lebar, a twenty(!) year veteran of web design and development. He is currently managing web and mobile development teams at Canada’s largest and most beloved classifieds site, Kijiji!

He is a father, sailor, snowboarder, skier, cyclist, writer, artist, graphic designer, classically trained musician and afraid of heights.

Adrian is not currently available for freelance and contract work. Learn more.

When we are unable to find tranquility within ourselves, it is useless to seek it elsewhere.”
- Francois de La Rochefoucauld


  • I remember designing and building the original Playdium website in 1996 (I have screen caps somewhere of the work w… Wednesday October 14, 2020
  • Enough of this, 2020, already. Eddie Van Halen, rest easy, man. Tuesday October 6, 2020
  • It is amazing how quickly one adjusts to their glasses constantly steaming up, isn’t it? Monday October 5, 2020
  • Seriously, no amount of ‘weird tricks that Warren Buffet uses’ are going to improve anyone’s life. Friday September 25, 2020
  • Was just pondering about how both writing and programming can rewrite your brain, and came to the following, which… Friday September 18, 2020
  • Sony was, like, one front dial away from converting me over to their Full Frame cameras. One dial. Monday September 14, 2020
  • Tuesday August 25, 2020
  • @mrmatthogg You certainly want to work with him. Tuesday May 12, 2020
  • @mrmatthogg Lately you sound like me 3 years ago, failing agains the profligate use of users bandwidth and computin… Monday May 11, 2020