Lather. Rinse. Repeat. Monday December 24, 2007, 5 comments

When I was about nine I read first The Hobbit, then The Lord of the Rings, by J.R.R. Tolkien. While I found the trilogy a bit ponderous for my young mind, The Hobbit really captured my imagination and catapulted me into the serious fantasy genre.

From fantasy I moved boldly into science fiction, where I discovered Asimov’s Foundation trilogy, Adams’ Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy (a “five-part trilogy of four”) and eventually Pratchett’s Discworld – a triumphant return to fantasy. While none of these are the pinnacle of literary greatness, I have read hundreds and hundreds of worthy books, all because in a hole in the ground there lived a Hobbit.

As you know, I just went and saw The Golden Compass, the feature-film adaptation of the first installment of Philip Pullman’s His Dark Materials trilogy. As I said in my review, Pullman manages to blend the fantasy and science-fiction genres brilliantly. You can read my review here.

But something else caught my attention while sitting in the darkened auditorium: how desperately the entertainment machine is searching for the next Harry Potter.

This is something that I’ve been sensing for the last few years. Movies like Eragon or Bridge to Terebithia are swimming in the wake of Rowling’s monster success with the boy wizard. Publishers have been signing new fantasy authors hand over fist in hopes of discovering the next big thing, and the trailers before The Golden Compass were no exception.

First was a trailer for a movie called Inkheart, a story about a girl with a gift for storytelling. It seems that any story she (or her father, it’s obviously genetic) reads aloud comes to life. Apparently one of them reads the wrong book, and brings to life a baddy named Capricorn, played by Andy Serkis of Gollum/Smeagol fame. I had never heard of Inkheart, but I was not really surprised to find out it was the first book in a trilogy.

Next came Spiderwick, a movie based on a book of the same title. Apparently two children move to an ancient New England estate named Spiderwick. There they find faeries and goblins and at least one troll. While it is clear there are a series of Spiderwick books, it is unclear if the movie is adapted from one or many of them.

While these fantasy books are a welcome change from Da Vinci code wanna-bes and spy stories, one cannot help but feel the market is being saturated in hopes of something “sticking” in the same way Harry Potter did. A similar thing happened after the success of the original Star Wars movie, and again with Pixar’s unique Toy Story. The entertainment industry, hungry for its fix of cheap profits, inundated us with formulaic knock-offs to no avail.

The Harry Potter and Star Wars series were undeniable successes. Pixar manages to make each release better than the one before it. These were gambles that broke open markets that were considered to be completely tapped out. But the reason for their successes cannot be broken down into a formula. A confluence of story, time and audience mindset made these stories more than the sum of their plot outlines. The answer is not in better special effects, or even more slick computer animation. It lies in stories that capture our collective imagination.

One can’t help but feel that if the entertainment industry were to spend as much energy exploring and developing new authors, stories and genres as it does trying to duplicate past successes, that the world would be a far more interesting place in which to read and watch movies.


sarah Monday December 24, 2007

I read recently that Peter Jackson has signed up to do two Hobbit movies. All I could think was ‘two Hobbit movies?!?’ Seems like a recipe for mediocrity to me. Drawing the book out for profit and nothing more, making it feel stretched.

Adrian Monday December 24, 2007

The Hobbit is an interesting one. On the one hand, Jackson and the studio are going to milk the success of LoTR, on the other hand, the Hobbit was a true part of the story of the Ring, so it should have been made anyway.

I do agree though, one Hobbit movie would have sufficed, while two cheapens the whole thing.

Daniel Black Tuesday December 25, 2007

Might be tempted to agree; but at the same time, I like Peter Jackson’s dedication to quality as evinced in the LoTR movies. There’s something to be said for someone able to wrangle things such that there are 10 hours of fine craft, taken as a whole.

There is, and likely always was/will be, a fine line between reproduction toward the mediocrity of profit, and reproduction toward the success of a new facet given to an old jewel. Each of the Mad Max movies has both a shared signature environment, and a personality distinct from the other two. The second Saw movie was the best of the bunch. I can say the same for Hostel 2: it was obvious that Roth avoided trying to merely increase the volume of blood, but rather to tell a more compelling and involved story, with character studies worth investigating. It wasn’t as shocking, gratuitously; but it was a bit more thought-provoking than his first installment.

On the flip side, The Golden Compass looks very much like the poor attempt at the fantasy market that the first Narnia movie was. That thing was shite. Someone needs to do something fresh, and there’s plenty to be done, really. I want to see both the original Metropolis, as well as the anime remake, because I expect them to be similar but to have room for nuanced dissimilarity and originality.

Then, there’s Iron Man. I’m seein’ me some Iron Man.

Daniel Black Wednesday December 26, 2007

Also, it’s arguable that the remake of Dawn of the Dead has greater merits than the original in some ways.

Daniel Black Wednesday December 26, 2007

Commenting has ended for this post, but I'd still love to hear from you.

The website of Adrian Lebar

A Rain of Frogs is written, designed and built by Adrian Lebar, a twenty(!) year veteran of web design and development. He is currently managing web and mobile development teams at Canada’s largest and most beloved classifieds site, Kijiji!

He is a father, sailor, snowboarder, skier, cyclist, writer, artist, graphic designer, classically trained musician and afraid of heights.

Adrian is not currently available for freelance and contract work. Learn more.

There is little elegance in complexity.”
- Adrian Lebar


  • I remember designing and building the original Playdium website in 1996 (I have screen caps somewhere of the work w… Wednesday October 14, 2020
  • Enough of this, 2020, already. Eddie Van Halen, rest easy, man. Tuesday October 6, 2020
  • It is amazing how quickly one adjusts to their glasses constantly steaming up, isn’t it? Monday October 5, 2020
  • Seriously, no amount of ‘weird tricks that Warren Buffet uses’ are going to improve anyone’s life. Friday September 25, 2020
  • Was just pondering about how both writing and programming can rewrite your brain, and came to the following, which… Friday September 18, 2020
  • Sony was, like, one front dial away from converting me over to their Full Frame cameras. One dial. Monday September 14, 2020
  • Tuesday August 25, 2020
  • @mrmatthogg You certainly want to work with him. Tuesday May 12, 2020
  • @mrmatthogg Lately you sound like me 3 years ago, failing agains the profligate use of users bandwidth and computin… Monday May 11, 2020